6 Best Crappie Lures 2021

Crappie fishing is just as fun as any other type of fishing, so if you see everyone else around you on the lake reeling them in one after another while you sit idle on the shore or in your boat, you need some advice.

Our advice to you is to read our list below.

We highlight some of the best crappie lures and jigs because we know that many laws prevent you from using live minnows. Where is the challenge in live minnows anyway?

Try some of these.

The Lures that Work

Here are the top crappie lures to consider.

  • Imitation Minnows
  • Jigs (feathered, loose or split tail)
  • Crankbaits
  • Spinners
  • Tubes
  • Grubs

Anything that imitates a minnow is standard in the crappie fishing box, and we’ll show you some below.


These seem to be the most popular and effective colors when it comes to crappie fishing, and as always, it depends on where you fish. Having a selection and a mixture of colors is always a good idea so you can switch them out to see what works on that particular day.

Mixing any of the following colors together in the same lure can also be very helpful.

  • Green
  • Chartreuse
  • Red
  • Pink
  • Grey
  • Black

Where You Fish

Where you fish will determine the lure and gear you use.

  • Shore. If you fish from the shore, you’ll need weights and a bobber to help you achieve the ideal depth.
  • Trolling. If you’re trolling, you’ll need a decent crankbait or spinner rather than a jig. The size depends on the size of crappie that you want to catch and how big they usually get in the waters you’re fishing.

Smaller crappie goes after smaller prey and larger crappie will head for the larger prey. If you want to catch larger crappie and you know that they’re down there, tempt them with the correct bait size!

Time of Year

Food preferences and swimming depth changes based on the time of year, so remember that the lure you use in the summer months might not be as effective in the winter.

If your lures and jigs aren’t working, you may need to adjust the depth that it sinks to or change your position on/around the lake.

Top 6 Crappie Lures Comparison Table

PictureNameTypePriceRating (1-5)
Rating (1-5)
1. Bobby Garland BS182-P Shad grub$4.7
2. Berkley SCMI2-BS Minnow$4.6
3. FOVONON Crankbaits Set Crankbait$$4.6
4. Eagle Claw Crappie Jig Jig$$4.6
5. Yakima Bait Wordens Original Rooster Tail Spinner Lure Spinner$4.4
6. Ice Jigs - Marabou, Chenille - Crappie Jigs - Glow - Set of 6 Jig$$4.3

Top 3 Best Crappie Lures Reviews

While these seem to be some of the best crappie lures for many who fish, they may not provide you with the results you were hoping for.

If that’s the case, many of them come in different color combinations and you’re welcome to check out the other three options on our list, which are equally as good!

1. Bobby Garland BS182-P

Hungry crappie can’t resist the mouth-watering appeal of the Baby Shad crappie bait.

This comes as an 18 pack of one color, but there are seven other colors to choose from if the chartreuse red glitter pictured above isn’t the right one for you.

These are surprisingly effective, especially those that have hints of the chartreuse red in them. The profile of the shad and the taper of the tail allow it to flap and dance freely in order to attract the attention of crappie.

The bluegrass color is also a good one to try.

2. Berkley SCMI2-BS

If you’re looking for something that imitates a minnow more closely, then pick up a pack of these micro power minnows from Berkley.

Use them as jig trailers, spinner jobs or bottom bouncing rigs to attract crappie. Their lifelike design with bulging 3D eyes will tempt crappie and probably other fish nearby to take a bite.

When you can’t use real minnows, use the next best thing: these ready-to-fish minnow-like lures.

3. FOVONON Crankbaits Set

For trolling, get yourself a pack of crankbaits.

This set contains 5 lures and they come in a variety of colors that will allow you to select the right one based on your fishing conditions.

They’re smaller (1.18”) and best when used at shallow depths. A great little trolling lure for days when you’re out on the boat!

Number five is also worth a look if you’re trolling. It’s a great little spinner that comes in a variety of colors and it’s also great for catching bass.

Two excellent, multi-purpose lures that will help you attract the crappie.